Copycat Little Debbie Christmas Tree Cakes
This just might be the most nostalgic copycat recipe I’ve ever made. And of course because everything from scratch is better than store bought, they’re that much more delicious and special. The cake is vanilla forward, fluffy, and tender. The filling is smooth, sweet, fluffy, and delicious. Lastly, the entire coating has that signature texture and will just melt in your mouth.

Baking The Cake
I used two Quarter sheet pans to distribute my batter evenly. This is because, once the the cakes have cooled, they are stacked on top of each other with the filling in between the two layers. If you don’t have quarter sheet pans, you can use a standard half sheet pan and cut your finished cake in half to give you the two layers needed.


Making The Perfect Filling
The classic Little Debbie Christmas Tree Cake Filling is marshmallowy, sweet, smooth, fluffy, and pairs perfectly with the cake. That’s why in this recipe we are using a mixture of butter, confectioner’s sugar, vanilla, and marshmallow fluff. This filling is what you will recognize as a whoopie pie filling. But I promise you that as soon as you take a bit into these cakes, it’ll bring you back to your childhood.

It’s important to make sure that in the first step of this filling recipe that you cream the butter and marshmallow fluff together until there are no lumps. After you’ve added in the confectioner’s sugar it becomes much harder to work out any lumps so take the time to scrape down the sides of your bowl so you can have the most perfectly smooth filling.
Layering Copycat Little Debbie Christmas Tree Cakes
These tasty little desserts are the most festive, nostalgic and delicious addition to your Holiday season. Let’s go over how they’re layered.
The layers of these cakes before they’re decorated go, cake, filling, cake. To stack the cakes, gently take the cake that isn’t frosted and line it up with the frosted cake. Carefully flip it onto the frosted cake to create the layers.


It’s important to allow the cakes to chill in the freezer for the recommended times in the steps to ensure that the cakes are easier to work with and also don’t fall apart when cut into trees or dipped in the candy melts.

Coating Our Copycat Little Debbie Christmas Tree Cakes
Candy melts with a few tablespoons of coconut oil are going to help get our job done here. Candy melts are sweet and have a thin consistency which makes for the perfect coating for these Christmas cakes. The coconut oil just helps to maintain that thin texture to make our coating at a nice consistency.
More Recipes You May Be Interested In…
Gingerbread Millionaire Bars
Buddy The Elf Spaghetti Cookies
Vintage Santa Cake
What Is The Best Brownie Piece?
The Best Fudge Brownies
Little Debbie Christmas Tree Cheesecake
I hope you all enjoy this recipe as much as I do and taste the warmth and nostalgia in every bite! Happy Holidays and thank you all for your interest in my recipes, I am so lucky :)
















What a wonderful recipe! Listen to the recipe and fully chill the cake before cutting, that will solve any issue with the cake being sticky like some other comments mentioned. Or, if you don’t want to deal with a cookie cutter, just cut the cake into small squares. This recipe is too good not to try!
What brand of candy melts do you use? Wilton?
Hi there! I either use Wilton or Sweet Tooth Fairy from Michaels Craft Store :)
I have the white melting wafers from Walmart it says I do not need to add any extra ingredients— would you still add the coconut oil?
Hi there! I haven’t used Walmart melting wafers so I’m not sure what the exact consistency is like. I suggest melting them down as directed and seeing how the consistency looks. If they’re very thin off the bat then you don’t need to add any coconut oil. If it looks like it’s on the thicker side a bit then go ahead and add a tablespoon or two of coconut oil. The thinner the consistency the more even and smooth finish to coating your little Debbie tree cakes :) I hope this helps!!
This is the stickiest cake I’ve ever worked with. It stuck to everything and I could barely cut a decent, straight edge triangle out of it; let alone a cookie cutter shape. I was so disappointed. Maybe I’ll try again someday, but two wasted batches of these and a huge mess to clean up is more than enough to discourage me.
omg I had the same trouble. the cake was delicious but it was so sticky that the cutouts were a disaster :(
Hi Taylor! I am sorry to hear this :( The cakes are easier to work with and less sticky when chilled completely after being in the freezer. You can cut out one or two trees then place the tray back in the freezer for a bit to firm the cake up again. I hope this helps and hope you have a happy holiday season!!
Hi there – I am so sorry to hear this. The cakes will be sticky if they are not completely frozen. Please make sure to chill them in the freezer for at least one hour this makes them easier to work with. You can also freeze them we you cut out each tree so if you cut out one or two trees and the cake starts to soften, you can throw the pan back in the freezer so it’s easier to work with. I really hope you give this recipe another try. Happy holidays!!
All I have currently is self rising flour how would I use this in this recipe?
Hi there – I do not recommend using self rising flour as the leveling agents added into self rising flour may alter the overall outcome/ texture of the cake. If you can I recommend purchasing all-purpose flour for this recipe :)
Could you possibly do a video of you making these step by step please? I work better watching off a video.. Soo excited to make these for my family! Thanks!!
How large is the tree cookie cutter you use? Do you have a link to one? Thanks.
Hi there! I got this cookie cutter yeeearrs ago so I don’t remember where I got it from but a tree cutter anywhere from 3.5″ – 4″ is perfect for this recipe and Amazon is usually my go to place! :)
What size tree cutter? Also can white chocolate be used instead of white candy melts? Thanks
For the cutter, it can be any size you want! Mine’s about 3.5 – 4 inches tall – all cutters are unique.
As for the white chocolate, you can absolutely use it, but I’d recommend adding coconut oil to make it thinner, smoother, and easier to work with. It could potentially make the cake a bit soggy/not set as well as candy melts would. Totally depends on what chocolate you’re using. Let me know how it goes! :)
Thank you!!!
How did it go with the white chocolate?